Alicante Social Court No 3 (Juzgado de lo Social número 3) has ruled that the disciplinary dismissal of an employee at a parcels and logistics company was fair (procedente). The ruling was made in 2025.
According to the ruling, the employee regularly entered the company premises 30-45 minutes before her shift, which started at 07:30. The company had told her directly that she did not need to arrive so early, but she carried on. The court said that arriving too early against the company's warnings can count as misconduct, just as lateness can.
The court also looked at her clock-in records, the fichaje (electronic time-recording system). She logged out while she was already outside the work centre, in some cases several kilometres away, which misrepresented how long she had actually been on site. The court also found that she had repeatedly failed to follow management instructions.
The court treated this combination as a serious breach of her work duties and a breach of good faith in the employment relationship (quiebra de la buena fe contractual). Because the dismissal was ruled fair, the company does not have to pay compensation for it. It must still pay any outstanding sums owed to the employee.
Juanma Lorente, the employment lawyer who reviewed the case, said he had seen dismissals for lateness, unexcused absence and poor discipline before, but not for arriving early. In his view, the key issue is not the arrival time but the refusal to follow the company's instructions.
The court treated ignoring an employer's instruction on arrival times as a breach of discipline. It is not yet known whether the ruling has been appealed.


