The Court of Justice of the European Union (TJUE) has ruled that banks must refund customers immediately for money taken in unauthorised payments. In its judgment of 15 October in case C-70/25, the court said a bank cannot delay or refuse a refund on the grounds that the customer may have been grossly negligent.

The case involved a woman from Poland who was trying to sell an item online. A fake buyer sent her a link that copied her bank's website. Fraudsters used it to get her access details and make payments. The court had to decide whether the bank must repay the money when there were signs the customer might have been grossly negligent.

The ruling interprets the EU Payment Services Directive, which Spain brought into its law through Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 (Real Decreto-ley 19/2018). Under Article 45, the bank must refund the amount at once, and no later than the end of the working day after it learns of the transaction or the customer reports it. The only exception is a well-founded suspicion that the customer committed the fraud. In that case, the bank must give its reasons in writing to the competent national authority. A mere suspicion of carelessness is not enough to withhold a refund.

Article 46 says a customer can be held liable for losses if they acted fraudulently, or if they deliberately or through gross negligence broke their security obligations. That can no longer be used as a reason to block the initial refund. If the bank believes the negligence was gross, it can ask for the money back later. It must then prove it has legal grounds to do so.

The ruling has limits. It does not require banks to refund every sum lost to fraud, only unauthorised payment transactions. If the customer made the payment after being tricked by a third party, it may be classed differently, and the protection does not apply automatically. If a customer shared login details, confirmation codes or remote access to a device, the bank still cannot refuse the initial refund. However, those facts can be considered later, when gross negligence is assessed. Adicae warns that cases differ. If a customer gave access to a computer, or followed the instructions of a supposed financial adviser, gross negligence is judged separately.

Julián Tío, director of the Asociación Valenciana de Consumidores y Usuarios (Avacu), believes the change makes it easier for victims to get their money back. He advises filing a police report first, then making a claim to the bank. Stella Maris López, Adicae's official mediator in Spain, says that where a bank once cited gross negligence, the customer may have had to go to court. Now the bank refunds first and asks for the money back afterwards. Consumer groups call the ruling a small victory. The banks see it as a change of procedure that will not significantly affect their accounts. According to several consumer groups, losses from unauthorised transactions in fraud cases can in some cases reach €40,000.

It is not yet known when the new procedure will apply in Spain. The Bank of Spain (Banco de España), Spain's Ministry of Consumer Affairs and the banks have not yet made any statement.