Article 18 of Spain's Ley de Propiedad Horizontal (LPH, the Horizontal Property Act) sets out when and how a decision of a comunidad de vecinos (community of owners) can be challenged. A court can be asked to annul a decision that breaks the law or the community's estatutos (statutes). Other grounds are that the decision seriously harms the community's interests in favour of one or more owners, or that it causes serious damage to an owner who is not legally obliged to put up with it. A decision taken in abuse of rights can also be challenged.
Owners who voted against at the meeting (salvaron su voto), owners who did not attend, and owners who were wrongly denied a vote can all bring a claim. Before filing, an owner must either pay any overdue debts to the community or deposit the disputed sums with the court (consignar judicialmente). That requirement does not apply if the challenge concerns setting or changing the participation shares (cuotas de participación).
The deadline is three months from the date of the decision. If the decision breaks the law or the statutes, the deadline is one year. Owners who were absent have the time counted from when they receive formal notice of the decision, given in the way the law requires.
Filing a claim does not suspend the decision. It stays in force unless the judge, after hearing from the community, orders a suspension as an interim measure (medida cautelar).
Article 19 of the LPH requires decisions to be recorded in a libro de actas (minute book), which is certified by the Property Registry (Registro de la Propiedad). The minutes must give the date and place, who called the meeting, who attended, the agenda and the decisions taken. Where it matters for the decision's validity, they must also say who voted for and against and what shares they represent. The chairman (presidente) and secretary (secretario) sign the minutes at the end of the meeting or within ten calendar days.




